Last year I wrote a blog about the state of professional
wrestling in 2011 in which I had many good things to say about the progression
that TNA had made and the emergence of CM Punk within the WWE as a major
superstar. Roughly one year on and although my wrestling viewing has been
sporadic, I have managed to keep abreast of the all the major developments and
PPVs.
If I was to judge in relative terms the progression each
company has made since last year I would say that TNA has made the greater
improvement. This year the company celebrates its 10 year anniversary, which I
believe is a great achievement and an important milestone, especially
considering how short lived WCW and ECW were in their heyday. TNA may not have
got their ‘Monday night war’ yet, which has almost become a rite of passage
amongst potential rivals of the WWE, but the company have made massive strides
to correcting the mistakes of the initial Hogan/Bischoff era. If the company is
to be seen as a legitimate alternative to the WWE then longevity is important.
And legitimacy is what TNA is earning for itself, little by
little; this month saw TNA host its second largest annual PPV – Slammiversary,
one of the best PPV’s of 2012 so far. The PPV showcased all that is good about
TNA: the star power and quality of its roster as well as the intelligent
booking that is slowly becoming more of a primary feature of the company. I
want to just highlight some of the features of Slammiversary that I believe are
examples of just how far TNA has come – firstly the promotion of ‘original’ and
indie talent over ex-WWE superstars. Slammiversary opened with an X-Division
title match between Austin Aries and Samoa Joe. Austin Aries has proven to be a
star signing and one of the biggest revelations of 2012. The first ever X2 ROH
world champion that should tell you something of the calibre of this performer;
Aries is one of the best all round wrestlers in the business and epitomises
what is great and innovative about the X-Division, something that has always
set TNA apart from the WWE. Aries and Joe are two of TNA’s most successful
indie transfers and really give the company that air of credibility.
Following on from the inclusion on the roster of ‘The
greatest man that ever lived’, ‘A-Double’ Austin Aries, is the way in which TNA
are using their ex-WWE superstars who bring much needed star power to the
promotion. Slammiversary saw the tag team of AJ Styles and Kurt Angle, two of
TNA’s greatest world champions as they faced off against reigning tag champions
Christopher Daniels and Kazarian. The chemistry of Styles and Angle worked well
and the gelling and harmonising of TNA’s first ever grand slam champion and
arguably TNA’s biggest ex-WWE signing is a great example of the way in which
ex-WWE talent is being used correctly to undergird the quality of the roster
and the booking without creating an elitist inner circle for themselves.
Moreover RVD, Mr Anderson and Jeff Hardy put on a tremendous triple threat
match, which included some amazing spots, proving that for three seasoned
veterans that they can still entertain while putting their egos aside as the upper
mid card without the diva attitude of ‘I’m only here to be world champion’.
Slammiversary benefited all the more from these three individuals’ contribution
and performances without them needing to muscle their way into the main event.
Slammiversary was also the venue of the announcement of the
inaugural TNA Hall of Famer – none other than the icon Sting. It is debatable
whether Sting should have been the first Hall of Fame inductee but he is
certainly worthy of it. Sting has been a massive edition to TNA these past 6
years and has been used to put over several TNA world champions, while steering
the ship in troubled waters such as Jeff Hardy’s drug induced self-destruction
a couple of years ago. Sting has led by example over this past year, showing
the next generation how to give your best performance week after week and how
to remain relevant in an ever evolving wrestling landscape. His Joker gimmick
of last year was a stroke of genius and proved that he still belongs within the
contemporary wrestling scene unlike some of his peers, who have only disgraced
themselves by their shameless self-aggrandisement and living off of their past
reputations ala Rick Flair. Sting may have toyed with finally moving to the WWE
over the past few years, but he has stayed loyal to TNA and I think TNA have
made the right decision in inducting him into their Hall of Fame. Conversely,
Sting’s biggest contribution to Slammiversary was in his main event title match
against Bobby Roode.
Roode is currently the longest reigning TNA world champion
and one of the best TNA ‘originals’ the company has produced. Roode is one of
the biggest indicators of how far the company has come to reversing some of the
questionable booking decisions of a couple of years ago. Roode is a homemade
star within TNA and his rise to success has been well planned and executed –
Roode has been attempting to break through the glass ceiling for a little while
and has finally smashed through it with a vengeance. Roode has played the heel
superbly over the course of his title reign proving that he deserves to be the
flag bearer for TNA. What is more exciting though is not just the fact that
Roode has made TNA history in this historic year but also how his break up and
relationship with former tag partner and Beer Money member James Storm has
played out. Storm returned at Slammiversary to take Crimson’s unbeaten streak
in emphatic fashion in what appears to be a slow burn push leading to his own
world title run, hopefully at Bound for Glory. Again Storm is another example
of TNA promoting their ‘in-house’ talent and turning them into bona fide main
eventers and world champions. TNA are certainly moving in the right direction
with Roode and Storm at the helm.
What is particularly encouraging is the fact that TNA’s
adopted mantra from last year ‘Wrestling Matters’ is still alive and well and
has become engrained within the spirit and philosophy of the company. While it
worked as way of differentiating themselves from the WWE who have taken the
opposite approach to their marketing in recent times it would have been
disappointing had it been only empty rhetoric. But TNA have proved that after
10 rocky years they have a lot to be proud of and many accomplishments to deservedly
celebrate.
The WWE in comparison has had in many respects a mediocre
year so far. The year started well with the mysterious ‘end of the world as you
know it’ vignettes, which sadly fizzled out and proved a complete anti-climax
when Jericho returned for the second time only to go on a losing streak, which
continued all the way up to his suspension while at a house show in Brazil last
month. Jericho had a great feud with Punk, one of the highlights of 2012 for me
as his promos mimicked Punk’s ‘pipe bombs’ of 2011 cutting close to the bone
and becoming extremely personal. Their match at Wrestle Mania 28 was the best
of the night for me from a traditional wrestling stand point. Punk himself is currently
enjoying an 8 month winning streak becoming one of the longest reigning WWE
champions in recent memory. This has been a master stroke for the WWE who were
guilty not so long ago of devaluing their prestigious world title. While some
fans may be growing tired of Punk by now and complain that he is stagnating as
champion, I think he is one of the most convincing champions the WWE have and
has given back much of the legitimacy that the WWE was in danger of losing.
Two
other superstars who have risen to prominence at the moment are Sheamus and
Daniel Bryan. Sheamus’ face turn has been successful and his world title reign
has been far more credible than his two previous WWE titles, both of which were
short lived and distasteful, not to mention a travesty of his heel character.
However, face Sheamus is finally enjoying the dominance on Smack Down that he
deserves and I hope the WWE continue to book him strongly as he is one of the
best legitimate heavyweights the WWE have. Daniel Bryan has brought his technical
hard style indie wrestling that made him so popular in ROH to the WWE and has
proven that there is a place for technical wrestling at the highest level of
the all too often glamorous and over stylised main event scene. Despite this I
felt WWE were wrong to have Bryan put Sheamus over in just 18 seconds at
Wrestle Mania this year – Bryan deserved better.
Another irritating factor about Wrestle Mania 28 was the
‘end of an era’ Undertaker v HHH Hell in a Cell match, which ended... nothing!
The language was apocalyptic and Armageddon was promised but what was delivered
was just another, albeit excellent, streak match that saw Undertaker reach the
unprecedented feat of 20-0. What disappointed me the most was the finish –
unlike last year that saw a very human Undertaker leave the arena, this year
Undertaker was allowed to dominate a beaten and battered HHH, who again showed
far too much mercy despite vowing not to! And although there were several mark
out moments for me, especially hitting Taker over the head with a sledge hammer
and HBK connecting sweet chin music followed by a pedigree from HHH, Undertaker
still managed to pummel the fight out of HHH until he could continue no more.
The fact that an aging, injured Undertaker who is for the best part retired
from the active roster and only wrestles now one match a year at Wrestle Mania
was allowed to go over HHH so cleanly in the end was a disgrace. There was no
swerve, no twist, no controversy and no double crossing, just Undertaker being
made to look invincible. The streak, no doubt, will continue and as HHH has
reprised his role as COO on screen it looks as if everything will go on as
normal proving that in fact the end of an era was nothing more than empty
rhetoric designed to sell a match.
Another failure in my eyes was the long anticipated comeback
of Brock Lesnar. Lesnar returned the night after Wrestle Mania to the joy and
euphoria of the fans but immediately the WWE booked themselves into a no win
situation. Brock’s first action was to F5 Cena and set up a match at Extreme
Rules. Cena had just come off of a surprise loss to the Rock the previous
night. If Cena lost to two returning opponents at two PPVs back to back then it
would send the implicit message that the current generation of WWE superstars are
subpar compared to previous generations, and yet if Brock lost in his first
match back in the WWE it would make him look weak and destroy any momentum he
had at his return. In the end the latter proved the case as Brock lost and then
kayfabe injured HHH’s arm leading him to ‘quit’ the WWE only a month after his
triumphant return.
Dolph Ziggler continues to be on the cusp of his big break
through, which has been teased many times over the past couple of years but to no avail.
For some reason WWE are reluctant to pull the trigger on Ziggler, despite him
being used as a fall back guy when needed. Ziggler is one of the best
performers the WWE have and sells moves and takes bumps like no other and yet
still he is stuck in mid card limbo unable to break from Vicky Guerro. I
am beginning to fear for Ziggler now that his time may never come, at least not
in the way his talent deserves.
So all in all WWE have blundered through 2012 with some
booking triumphs and mistakes. For me nothing that the WWE has done this year has
set the wrestling world on fire like MITB last year when Punk beat Cena in an
historic night and the culmination of one of the greatest storylines of the 21st
Century. Maybe it is unfair to compare the WWE of 2012 with that of 2011 for
that very reason but at the end of the day the WWE have set themselves a
precedent now. For me while still a long way off from genuinely competing with
the WWE from a marketing and financial point of view, TNA has made the greater
improvement to the overall quality of their product and they deserve to be
given the credit this year for celebrating their 10 year anniversary. May TNA
enjoy 10 more years, which I am confident will be even better and more glorious
than the first.